First round to Lidl in trademark infringement dispute with Kroger

First round to Lidl in trademark dispute with Kroger

Kroger has lost its bid to gain a preliminary injunction that would immediately bar Lidl from using its 'Preferred Selection' name on its premium private label products.

In a lawsuit* filed June 30, Kroger argued that Lidl's Preferred Selection brand (featured on 160 items out of 3,000 typically stocked in a Lidl US store) is confusingly similar to its own 'Private Selection' private label brand, but following a day of testimony from both sides on July 25, US District Judge John A. Gibney Jr. denied Kroger’s request and set a trial date for January 11, 2018. 

While Gibney conceded that the logos look “somewhat alike,” he didn't find that they had "an identical or similar meaning," and noted that the words 'private' and 'preferred' have different meanings, The Richmond Times reported

In a statement sent to FoodNavigator-USA, Kroger said it was disappointed with the court's decision but vowed to continue fighting: "The Kroger Co. and our family of stores are extremely proud of Our Brands. We believe the merits of this case are clearly outlined in the complaint.

"We welcome fair competition and are disappointed with the court's ruling that was issued on July 25. We look forward to protecting our long-held trademarks in this ongoing litigation."

Lidl US, in turn, welcomed the ruling: "We are pleased with the court's ruling, which is a positive outcome for customers and market competition. Lidl is fully committed to delivering our customers the highest quality products at the lowest possible prices and our range will continue to include the Preferred Selection."

Read more about the case - and why attorneys we spoke to earlier this week predicted Kroger faced an uphill battle - HERE.

**The case is THE KROGER CO., and THE KROGER CO. OF MICHIGAN v. LIDL US, LLC and LIDL STIFTUNG & CO. KG, 3:17-cv-00480 filed in the eastern district of Virginia.

Related News

RAWBITE infringes LÄRABAR trademarks, alleges General Mills

RAW•BITE packaging is ‘strikingly’ similar to LÄRABAR, says General Mills lawsuit

Kroger's 'Private Selection' packaging is on the left, while Lidl's 'Preferred Selection' packaging is on the right...

Is Lidl infringing Kroger’s trademarks? Attorneys weigh in…

The bakery was a big hit with Lidl shoppers that spoke to Bernstein analysts this month

Lidl’s US business model will evolve, says Bernstein: ‘Aldi prices with Harris Teeter service and quality is not sustainable’

Lidl's US stores break European mold, says Bernstein

Lidl's US stores break European mold, says Bernstein: 'This is not a copy and paste approach'

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.