FDA offers to help industry draft guidance following Trump’s regulatory freeze

FDA offers to help industry draft guidance

Days after President Trump signed an executive order that freezes some regulations and draft guidance documents, FDA offers to help food industry associations draft their own guidance documents to help “capture the best practices” and boost industry compliance with federal laws and regulations. 

“FDA is not the only source of guidance documents on best practices for compliance with regulatory requirements” the agency notes in a Jan. 31 constituent update. “Associations or organizations associated with a specific industry and universities also draft guidance documents to capture the best practices to produce food, feed and other regulated products in a way that helps to ensure their safety in accordance with federal regulations.”

The agency adds in the update that it “can be involved in a number of ways” in the creation of these guidance documents, “including providing technical advice, looking out for potential conflicts with federal regulations and sharing its experience and insights.”

The agency’s offer could be a way for industry to glean insight into how FDA interprets the regulations and standards it enforces, despite the 60-day freeze on pending regulations and draft guidance documents signed by Trump Jan. 20. It also could be a way to advance progress on guidance documents even during the freeze.

While industry guidance might not hold as much water as those issued by FDA, USDA or other agencies, FDA notes in the update that they can influence the government’s policies in the long-term.

“Developing industry standards and best practices … can ultimately become part of an FDA guidance in the future,” the agency explains in the update.

5 tips for involving FDA

While FDA is open to working with trade groups and association to create draft guidance documents, the agency still has a full plate and will not have the resources to help with every proposal.

To increase the likelihood FDA will become involved in an association’s guidance process, it recommends associations first define the scope of the guidance document. How broad the guidance is, the extent of the industry’s need for the information and the usefulness of the guidance to FDA down the line in addressing topics not currently or planned to be covered by the agency, all factor into FDA’s decision to become involved, according to the memo.

Next it recommends creating a working group of diverse experts who have relevant interest or expertise on the matter, such as food industry representatives, consumer advocates, researchers, retailers and others in the state of federal government.

At this stage, before the guidance document is drafted, associations can reach out to FDA’s Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition for technical assistance, which the agency emphasizes is not mandatory but can take many forms, including reviewing and commenting on draft guidance, participating in webinars and joining face-to-face meetings.

When drafting the guidance, FDA recommends authors make the recommendations “as specific as possible and be science and risk-based.” Quantitative and qualitative risk assessments should be used as well as advice from subject matter experts. Participants also should brace for multiple rounds of review, the agency says.

Once the core group of advisers and authors are happy with the draft, it should then be circulated to a wider audience for evaluation, including to state and federal regulators, before it is finalized, FDA recommends. After this larger group’s comments are reviewed the guidance likely is ready for distribution and could be linked on FDA’s website for all stakeholders, if appropriate.

When all is said and done, this process generally takes about a year, which is notably longer than the current regulatory freeze, but it is a way to engage with the agency and other stakeholders during the freeze and in the period of likely uncertainty following. 

Related News

© iStock/Choreograph

Trump's executive order could upend current regulatory structure, experts say

© iStock/Willard

Enforcement likely to continue under Trump, with state AGs waiting in wings if it falters

Source: iStock

Draft guidance on using juice as color additives reopened for comments after transparency complaints

Picture:  American Enterprise Institute

GMA: Scott Gottlieb will be able to hit the ground running at FDA

Image: iStock/alfexe

Gottlieb or not, Trump budget threatens FDA says advocacy group

iStock photo.

FDA moves to organize inspectors along lines of expertise

Picture: FDA/Flickr

FSMA progress as FDA releases three final rules

Regulatory freeze could change or delay implementation aspects of FSMA, Nutrition Facts rule

Regulatory freeze could change or delay implementation aspects of FSMA, Nutrition Facts rule

Source: iStock

FDA’s 2016 food agenda prioritizes FSMA, product labeling, GRAS, GMOs

Source: iStock

Consumer food safety education must be reinforced to ‘reap the rewards’ of FSMA, FDA official says

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.