What do ‘natural’ and ‘clean label’ mean anyway?

What do consumers mean by 'natural'? And how does it correspond to food companies' idea of 'clean label'?

Market researchers tell us that consumers are seeking ‘natural’ products more than ever – and ingredient suppliers have responded by providing ways to ‘clean up’ product labels – but what do these terms really mean?

In the European Union, ‘natural’ is only clearly defined in EU regulation related to flavourings, while in the United States, the Food and Drug Administration has no formal definition, preferring to say that it won’t object as long as use of the term is “not misleading”.

Datamonitor’s innovation insights director Tom Vierhile says that consumers and food marketers alike are moving away from using the word natural on-pack, as they begin to recognise it as a ‘squishy’ term – although consumers may still be looking for the same attributes in their foods. However, instead of ‘natural’, they are looking for words like free-from, gluten-free, minimally processed, simple, and organic.

He says that this gamut of expressions more precisely covers what food manufacturers mean when they talk about ‘clean label’ foods and drinks.

“The conundrum when it comes to clean label is that there is really no definition of what clean label means,” Vierhile said. “…Not many packaged goods companies tend to use the term ‘clean label’ on their finished products.”

As for a working definition, he says that the primary implication of ‘clean label’ is transparency – in terms of the wholesomeness of ingredients, a lack of artificial ingredients, and often also a lack of common allergens.

Meanwhile, the number of products calling out their natural credentials on pack has been falling, from 8.8% of new products launched globally in 2007 to 6.3% this year, according to Datamonitor figures. (The proportion is much higher in the United States, but has still fallen, from 33% to 22% during the same time period). But other claims have been rising.

Gluten-free claims in particular have skyrocketed, featuring on 6.8% of new global product launches this year, from 2.9% in 2007. Again, the incidence is much higher in the US, where 16.7% of new products now make a gluten-free claim, up from 6.4% five years ago.

As the rise in such claims shows, booming consumer interest in minimally processed, allergen-free foods creates opportunities for manufacturers of processed foods, but it is also a major challenge.

Vierhile said: “Consumers attitudes are becoming decidedly more negative when it comes to processed foods.”


Tom Vierhile is the keynote speaker at the upcoming FREE-to-attend online event Natural & Clean Label Trends 2013, where he will discuss the meaning of natural and clean label in greater depth – as well as how manufacturers are responding to the trend.

The event is run by FoodNavigator.com and FoodNavigator-USA.com. For full details and to register, click here.

Related News

This warning letter headline 'contains' a word sure to get FDA’s attention

This warning letter headline 'contains' a word sure to get FDA’s attention

Univar: Cleaning up labels tops R&D agendas in 2014

Univar: Cleaning up labels tops R&D agendas in 2014

Food industry group wants permission to label GMO foods as ‘natural’

Food industry group wants permission to label GMO foods as ‘natural’

Free-from could go the same way as 'natural' labelling, warns Organic Monitor.

Free from 'free-from': Are consumers getting clean label lethargy?

Photo from Consumer Reports

Consumers seek out ‘natural’, ‘locally grown’ on product labels: survey

“Too many claims and the consumer is overwhelmed, but miss some out and you could be excluding a powerful motivator for purchase,” says Mintel analyst

Can too many simple ideas on pack get confusing?

Energy products & clean labels won't drive sales in 2015, NNB predicts

Energy products & clean labels will not drive sales in 2015, NNB predicts

Clean label headache for industry? “The technical issues they can handle, the health issue they can handle, but the social and ethical ones are [proving to be] much more of a challenge,” said Krishnakumar.

Clean label is the major concern for EU food firms

Clean label concerns are growing in Turkey - but taste and price may still be the main drivers of purchases. © iStock

Clean label on the rise in Turkey but price and taste still king

Quick byte-sized nuggets of nutritional information seemed to resonante well with consumers. ©iStock

Health-minded shoppers want easy-to-read label information

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast Defining, meeting consumer demand for clean label

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Defining and meeting consumer demand for clean label

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Top marketing strategies for natural products

Soup-To-Nuts Podcast: Clean label 2.0 and other top marketing strategies for natural products

Could the meaning of 'clean label' go beyond the idea of 'natural' with better consumer understanding?

Cleaner than clean: When natural is not enough

Demand for LycoRed's Tomat-O-Red natural lycopene colorant started to rocket last year after consumers told some big names in the trade that they didn't want crushed cochineal insects in their food

Natural colors: In conversation with LycoRed on why tomatoes trump bugs and beets

Does 'natural' amount to more than just a list of acceptable or unacceptable ingredients on a food label? What other cues are consumers looking for when deciding if a product is natural and wholesome? Find out on June 26 at Natural & Clean Label Trends 2013

Where do your products sit in the clean label hierarchy?

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (1)

Pie Hole Blogger - 21 Jun 2013 | 04:38

Everyone wants to feel special

The bottom line when reading label claims is to use your brain and read the nutrition information panel. If there's a claim like "simply nutritious" of "all natural" on a box of shortbread cookies... use your brain, are cookies healthy? Gluten and other allergen free claims are there to help people with those allergies or diseases... not for those of us who feel like we need a special label. Get tested by a medical doctor, no point cutting things out for no reason. People on gluten free diets who aren't actually diagnosed celiacs, usually only cut out major sources of gluten like bread or pasta, but still eat sauces or condiments that contain gluten... enough said. For more information and research on this topic (written by a dietitian) check out: http://www.pieholeblogger.com/2013/05/highfalutin-gluten.html http://www.pieholeblogger.com/2013/05/highfalutin-gluten-part-ii.html

21-Jun-2013 at 04:38 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.