Monster Energy 'truly sorry' for teen’s heart attack injury but denies responsibility

Monster 'truly sorry' for teen heart attack but denies responsibility

Monster Beverage Corporation has moved to quell investor disquiet as a jury trial starts to decide if it is liable for injury suffered by a teen whose mother claims its drinks caused his heart attack.

Yesterday a jury trial began in Durant, Bryan County, Oklahoma, with prosecutors claiming substantial damages from Monster.

Ongoing litigation/regulatory matters cost the firm $5m alone in Q1 2014, and despite Monster’s persistent ability to outperform the wider energy sector in the States, are raising investor concerns.

The Wheat trial is expected to last about a week, and is the first of three ongoing so-called ‘product liability and wrongful death’ claims hanging over the energy drinks giant to reach the trial stage.*

Coupled with wider attention in the US on safety issues surrounding energy drinks, this means the case will attract much media and industry interest.

Angela Wheat claims her 16 year-old son Jason Hamric drank a can of Monster Energy in November 2011, and later had a heart attack while working at Fairview Baptist Church.

Hamric survived, but Wheat’s lawsuit filed on January 23 2013 lawsuit against Monster and its distributor states that he still suffers from medical problems as a result of the incident she says resulted from his consuming Monster Energy, including slurred speech and memory problems.

Yesterday prosecutors working for Burrage Law Firm in Durant claimed in their opening remarks that Monster failed to properly label products; Wheat’s suit claims the drink was a “defective product” given “undisclosed high levels of caffeine” and other ingredients she says were dangerous.

Monster denies these claims, and told the court yesterday that the teen had a history of medical problems, while there was no proof he’d actually drunk Monster Energy before he collapsed.

News of the suit sent Monster’s share price down 4.53% to $64.74/share yesterday, and in a media statement released last night in response to media enquiries, the company said there was “no credible evidence” that Hamric even drank Monster Energy on that day in 2011.

A pastor at the church said he saw the teen with a ‘silver can’ on the day of the incident, Monster admits, but the brand says it had no product on sale that was even close to that description in 2011.

“We are truly sorry about Jason’s injury, but we are confident that once all the evidence is heard, it will be shown that Monster had no responsibility in this case,” the company said.

The company reiterated a claim it has made numerous times before. Namely, that 12bn Monster Energy drinks have been sold over the last 12 years, which “has shown that our products are safe”.

“Contrary to allegations, they are not ‘highly caffeinated’ and they are not marketed to children,” the company adds.

*The other cases are Wendy Crossland et al. v. Monster Beverage Corporation (concerning the death of Anais Fournier) and Paula Morris v. Monster Beverage Company (over the death of Alex Morris).

Related News

Cargill's market development manager Jack Heffern: “Consumers respond better to this idea of steady energy and fueling your body. It goes back to that physical benefit of energy...enabling them to work throughout the day." Photo credit:

‘Sustained energy’ not as powerful a message as we thought: Cargill

Wells Fargo Securities says Monster is keen to colonize the CSD space (Mike Mozart/Flickr)

Monster Energy trademarks Ultra Sunrise: Taking on Mountain Dew Kickstart?

Mike Mozart/Flickr

Coke poised to pounce on Monster Energy? Analyst suggests suitors wary of ‘legal overhang’

Dan Callahan: 'There is no medical, scientific or factual evidence to support the Maryland Medical Examiner's Report of 'caffeine toxicity' or that Ms. Fournier's consumption of two Monster Energy Drinks 24 hours apart contributed to, let alone was the cause of her untimely death'

Monster attorney: Medical evidence does not support allegation that Maryland teen died from ‘caffeine toxicity’

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.